Shelter Island Heights housing market,
at a glance.
8 active homes$4,372,500 median asking95 median days listed
As of . Active asking prices only, not sold prices and not an appraisal. Check official sources before acting.
These are the newest figures EuKreate has for Shelter Island Heights, measured 11 days ago. Newer figures are not available yet.
Shelter Island Heights market snapshot
As of
- Active homes
- 8
- Median asking price
- $4,372,500
- $1,999,999–$17,995,000
- Median price per sq ft
- $1,177/sq ft
- 4,250 sq ft typical
- Median days listed
- 95 days
- typically built 1948
What stands out today
- 50%listed over 90 days4 of 8 active homes.
Inventory age
50% of active homes have been listed more than 90 days. This reflects today's active inventory, not a trend over time.
- Under 60 days
- 37%
- 3 homes
- 60–90 days
- 13%
- 1 homes
- Over 90 days
- 50%
- 4 homes
What has changed
- Homes for sale8over 7 days, since
- Median asking price$4,372,500over 7 days, since
- Median price per sq ft$1,177over 7 days, since
- Median days on market95up 2.2%over 7 days, since
Homes for sale in Shelter Island Heights
6 of 6 homes · updated
| Address | Asking | Beds | Baths | Sq ft | Listed | Listed by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Bayview Ave | $3,895,000 | 4 | 6.5 | 5,377 | Douglas Elliman (Cutchogue) | |
| 13 Spring Garden Ave | $2,995,000 | 3 | 2.5 | 2,300 | Century 21 Excelsior Realty | |
| 11 Sunnyside Ave | $5,000,000 | 4 | 5.5 | 4,000 | Douglas Elliman - Sag Harbor | |
| 11 Prospect Ave | $2,200,000 | 4 | 2.5 | 1,994 | Sag Harbor | |
| 8 Brander Pkwy | $5,795,000 | 4 | 4 | 3,160 | Douglas Elliman - Sag Harbor | |
| 20 Prospect Ave | $4,995,000 | 7 | 6 | 5,000 | Hedgerow Exclusive Properties |
Newest first, never ranked. Active asking prices only, not sold prices and not an appraisal. Check official sources before acting.
Markets near Shelter Island Heights
Nearest first, by straight-line distance; not a view of where to buy.
- Shelter IslandSuffolk$2,900,000 median ask · 75 homes · 138 days
- GreenportSuffolk$1,100,000 median ask · 23 homes · 143 days
- East MarionSuffolk$1,497,000 median ask · 14 homes · 60 days
- SoutholdSuffolk$1,875,000 median ask · 40 homes · 90 days
- OrientSuffolk$2,250,000 median ask · 13 homes · 73 days
- PeconicSuffolk$2,024,500 median ask · 8 homes · 36 days
Explore Shelter Island Heights with EuKreate AI
Whether you are buying or selling, use local market context to understand your next move.
Search without an account; sign in only to save your research.
Active asking prices only, not sold prices and not an appraisal. Check official sources before acting. About this data
- Active asking prices only, not sold prices and not an appraisal. Check official sources before acting.
- Coverage is the areas EuKreate tracks, so this is not the whole market.
- How many homes went off the market is not shown: we have not been watching this area long enough for that number to mean anything.
- Whether a home is under contract is not in the data we receive, so no pending count is shown.